The NFM Blog

Comparing Shiitake and Maitake: The Differences

Mushrooms have been a mainstay in the culinary world for the longest of time but these days different types of mushrooms are gaining popularity for their potential health benefits. People are becoming aware that these fascinating fungi are dual-faceted. There are also plenty of variety of mushrooms available but not a lot of mushrooms can be used directly in cooking and as well as be ingested for health benefits. Shiitake and Maitake mushrooms beg to differ, however. These two mushrooms have been omnipresent in both the culinary world and as well as the mushroom supplement world. It’s time to pit them against each other and see which of these versatile mushrooms comes out on top.

The main event is Shiitake vs Maitake. These mushrooms boast distinct personalities. The Maitake nicknamed the "Hen of the Woods," resembles a feathery crown or cascading waterfall of mushrooms, with its fan-like structure and cascading, frilled "feathers." It often boasts an earthy, woodsy flavor, holding a special place in Japanese cuisine and traditional medicine.

The Shiitake is a familiar face in Asian cuisine and is easily recognizable by its dark brown cap, lighter stem, and umbrella-like shape. With a meaty texture and a savory, umami taste, shiitake is a versatile culinary hero.

But beyond their appearances, what truly sets these mushrooms apart? Let's find out about these fungi truly to understand the unique nutritional profiles, health benefits, culinary applications, and environmental considerations of maitake and shiitake mushrooms.

A Nutritional Powerhouse

Both maitake and shiitake are nutritional powerhouses, offering a unique blend of vitamins, minerals, and bioactive compounds that contribute to their potential health benefits. Let's delve deeper and explore what each mushroom brings to the table:

  • Maitake: The Antioxidant Champion: This feathery friend shines with its rich content of antioxidants, compounds that help protect your cells from damage. Additionally, maitake boasts an abundance of proteins, essential building blocks for your body, and glycoproteins, complex molecules that play various roles in cellular function.

Perhaps most notably, maitake is a powerhouse of polysaccharides, a type of complex carbohydrate found in mushrooms. Among these polysaccharides are beta-glucans, which have been linked to supporting a healthy immune system. Studies suggest beta-glucans may activate immune cells, potentially aiding your body's defense against illness and improve gut health as well.

  • Shiitake: The Umami Powerhouse with Potential Health Benefits: Don't underestimate the shiitake! It's a good source of lentinan, a polysaccharide with potential anti-cancer properties. Studies suggest lentinan may help stimulate the immune system and potentially play a role in inhibiting the growth of certain cancer cells. Additionally, shiitake offers a noteworthy amount of copper, a mineral essential for various bodily functions, including energy production and connective tissue formation.

Shiitake is also high in polysaccharides and polysaccharopeptides, which contribute to its umami flavor – that savory, brothy taste that adds depth to your dishes. These polysaccharides may also offer additional health benefits, although more research is needed to fully understand their potential impact.

Exploring the Health Potential – Benefits Beyond the Plate

While both maitake and shiitake are delicious additions to your meals, their potential health benefits are what truly make them stand out. Here's a closer look at the potential ways these mushrooms might contribute to your well-being:

  • Maitake:  Studies suggest that maitake may support your immune system, potentially aiding in your body's defense against illness. Additional research suggests maitake may play a role in weight management by promoting feelings of satiety and regulating blood sugar levels. Its antioxidant properties might also contribute to overall health and potentially reduce oxidative stress in the body.

  • Shiitake: A Potential Friend for Your Heart, Liver, and Skin: Shiitake might be your heart's new best friend. Studies suggest it may help lower cholesterol levels and improve blood pressure, potentially contributing to cardiovascular health. Additionally, shiitake might support healthy liver function by promoting detoxification and aiding in the breakdown of fats. Some studies also suggest that shiitake may promote beautiful skin by supporting collagen production and potentially reducing inflammation. Shiitake's antimicrobial properties might also offer some protection against unwanted bacteria.

Get Cooking: Unleashing Culinary Creativity with Maitake vs Shiitake

The beauty of shiitake vs maitake lies not just in their health potential, but in their culinary versatility. With their distinct textures and flavors, these mushrooms can elevate your dishes to new heights:

  • Maitake: The Feathery Friend for Creative Dishes: Embrace the unique, feathery texture of maitake in stir-fries. The delicate strands add a touch of elegance and absorb the flavors of other ingredients beautifully. Maitake also shines in soups, lending a delightful textural contrast to broth-based dishes. For a more adventurous culinary experience, consider incorporating maitake into pastas or even risottos. The earthy flavor pairs well with a variety of ingredients, making it a delicious and nutritious addition to your culinary creations. For a vegetarian twist, try using maitake as a meat substitute in tacos or fajitas.

  • Shiitake: The Umami Hero in Asian and Beyond: A staple in Asian cuisine, shiitake reigns supreme in broths, stir-fries, and noodle dishes. Its meaty texture makes it a perfect vegetarian substitute for meat, adding a satisfying bite to vegetarian and vegan dishes. The umami flavor of shiitake adds depth to sauces and marinades, making it a versatile ingredient for creating flavorful meals. Roasted shiitake mushrooms can be a delightful, savory side dish. Marinate them in your favorite herbs and spices, then roast until tender and slightly crispy for a simple yet satisfying accompaniment to any meal.

A Sustainable Feast: Environmental Impact and Considerations

Both maitake and shiitake are considered environmentally friendly choices. These mushrooms are typically cultivated on wood logs or other organic materials, making them a more sustainable option compared to some protein sources. However, opting for locally grown and organic options whenever possible is always a good practice. This not only minimizes your carbon footprint but also ensures the mushrooms are grown without harmful pesticides or chemicals. Look for certifications from reputable organizations to ensure organic practices are followed.

Price and Availability: Finding Your Fungus Friend

Shiitake mushrooms are generally more readily available than maitake and tend to be more budget-friendly. Their popularity in Asian cuisine has led to wider cultivation and distribution, making them easier to find in most grocery stores. Maitake, on the other hand, might be less readily available and can be priced slightly higher due to its perceived rarity. However, some specialty stores and online retailers might offer maitake mushrooms at competitive prices.

Quality Matters: Choosing the Best Mushrooms

Whether you choose maitake or shiitake, selecting high-quality, toxin-free mushrooms is crucial. Here are some tips to ensure you're getting the best:

  • Look for Freshness: Choose firm, fresh mushrooms with no blemishes or discoloration. Any signs of sliminess or mold should be avoided.
  • Consider Organic Options: Organic mushrooms are typically grown without harmful pesticides or chemicals, potentially offering additional health benefits and peace of mind.
  • Check the Source: If buying from a farmers market or specialty store, inquire about the growing practices to ensure responsible and sustainable cultivation.


The information has been laid out and ultimately the choice comes down to personal preference when it comes to Shiitake vs Maitake. Both offer unique flavor profiles when it comes to cooking them and their health benefits are varied but might overlap here and there. It comes down to you as to what you like more. 

Embrace the Adventure: Exploring the World of Mushrooms

The world of mushrooms is vast and fascinating, offering a treasure trove of culinary delights and potential health benefits. Maitake and shiitake are just two superstars in this diverse kingdom. As you delve deeper into the world of fungi, you might discover other exciting varieties, each with its unique flavor profile and potential health contributions.

Here are some additional tips for exploring the world of mushrooms:

  • Consult a Foraging Guide (with Caution): If you're interested in foraging for wild mushrooms, it's crucial to consult a reliable foraging guide and only collect mushrooms you can confidently identify as safe for consumption. Many wild mushrooms can be poisonous, so exercising extreme caution is essential.
  • Explore Farmers Markets and Specialty Stores: Farmers markets and specialty stores often offer a wider variety of mushrooms than traditional grocery stores. Talk to the vendors and learn about the different types of mushrooms available, their culinary uses, and potential health benefits.
  • Experiment with Different Recipes: With a little creativity, you can incorporate a variety of mushrooms into your meals. From creamy mushroom soups to hearty stews and flavorful pasta dishes, the possibilities are endless!

By embracing the diverse world of mushrooms, you can not only expand your culinary horizons but also potentially unlock a new dimension of health and well-being. So, the next time you're at the grocery store or farmers market, take a moment to explore the fascinating world of fungi. You might just discover your new favorite ingredient and unlock a world of delicious and potentially health-promoting possibilities!

If you are someone who doesn’t like the taste of mushrooms but is still looking to incorporate the benefits of mushrooms, look no further than Non-Fungible Mushrooms. The Mushroom Adaptogen Powders are of the highest quality, 100% organic, non-GMO, vegan, and gluten-free, and contain absolutely no fillers, sugars, or harmful sweeteners.

We pride ourselves in sourcing/manufacturing the absolute best, our mushrooms are pure, and the potency is elite! Discover 5 different Mushroom Adaptogen blends! Our personal favorite is the LIFE – Mushroom Adaptogen Powder  LIFE contains the 6 most powerful and beneficial mushrooms including Maitake! We call it our “mushroom multi” because of its versatility. 

  • Good for gut health
  • Supports with steady energy throughout the day
  • Balances the immune system
  • Boosts brain power