There’s a universe of difference between the dusty can of “cocoa” in the baking aisle and true, vibrant, nutrient-dense cacao powder. It’s a distinction we’re passionate about here at Non Fungible Mushrooms. One is a heavily processed, heat-treated shadow of its former self. The other is a powerhouse of flavor and wellness, a cornerstone of ancient traditions. So, when people ask us how to make cacao powder, we get excited. Because they’re not just asking for a recipe; they’re asking how to unlock the genuine potential of one of nature’s most incredible gifts.
Let’s be honest, this isn’t a five-minute kitchen project. It’s a journey. It’s a craft. It’s an appreciation for a process that honors the ingredient at every step. Our team has dedicated itself to sourcing the most pristine ingredients on the planet, from potent functional mushrooms to the incredible Chuncho Cacao - From Peru we offer. We believe that understanding the how deepens your connection to the what. And making your own cacao powder is the ultimate way to connect with this amazing superfood.
Before we dive into the nitty-gritty, we need to clear the air on a massive point of confusion. Cacao and cocoa are not the same. They both start from the same place—the bean of the Theobroma cacao tree—but their paths diverge dramatically. This isn't just marketing speak; it's a fundamental difference in processing that has a profound impact on the final product's nutritional profile and flavor.
Cocoa powder is what most of us grew up with. It's produced by roasting cacao beans at very high temperatures. This process, known as Dutch processing, often involves an alkalizing agent to reduce acidity, darken the color, and create a milder flavor. The downside? That intense heat obliterates a significant portion of the delicate antioxidants and phytonutrients that make cacao so beneficial. It’s easier to mass-produce, but you lose the soul of the bean.
Raw cacao powder, on the other hand, is the result of a much gentler, low-temperature process. The beans are fermented, dried, and then cold-pressed to separate the fat (cacao butter) from the solids. These solids are then ground into the fine powder you see. By skipping the high-heat roasting, raw cacao powder retains an astonishingly high level of antioxidants, magnesium, iron, and other vital minerals. Its flavor is more complex, fruity, and slightly bitter—a true expression of the bean. This commitment to purity is why we're in this business. Pure, Organic, Potent — Every Scoop Matters!
You can't create a masterpiece with cheap paint. The same principle applies here. The quality of your finished cacao powder is entirely dependent on the quality of the beans you start with. This is the single most important decision you'll make in the entire process. We can't stress this enough.
Look for raw, unroasted, fermented cacao beans. You'll want to find a supplier who can tell you about the bean's origin and varietal. There are three main types: Criollo (rare, prized for its complex flavor), Forastero (hardy, makes up the bulk of the world's chocolate), and Trinitario (a hybrid of the two). Our experience has led us to heirloom varieties like the Chuncho beans from Peru, which we offer directly to our community. These beans are known for their incredibly low bitterness and rich, fruity flavor profile, making them perfect for creating a superior powder at home.
When your beans arrive, inspect them. They should have a slightly acidic, vinegary, chocolatey smell. This is a good sign! It means they’ve been properly fermented. They should be dry to the touch and relatively uniform in size. Avoid beans that look moldy, have an off smell, or are broken into tiny pieces.
Okay, here's where we separate the amateurs from the artisans. Many online guides will tell you to just buy nibs and grind them. That doesn't make cacao powder. That makes ground nibs. The magic, the deep, resonant flavor of true chocolate, is born in fermentation.
If you've sourced high-quality, pre-fermented beans (like the ones we provide), you can skip this step. But if you ever find yourself with fresh beans straight from the pod, this is the crucial transformation. The beans, still coated in their sweet, white pulp, are placed in wooden boxes or wrapped in banana leaves and left to ferment for several days. It's a two-stage microbial dance. First, yeasts flock to the sugary pulp, converting it into alcohol. As the temperature rises and oxygen gets in, acetic acid bacteria take over, converting the alcohol into acetic acid (the same stuff in vinegar). This process does two vital things:
This is a complex biological process that artisan producers have perfected over centuries. It's the first and most important expression of terroir and craftsmanship. It’s biotechnology in its most ancient and delicious form.
After fermentation, the beans are wet and need to be dried to a moisture content of around 7% to be stable for storage. The traditional method is sun-drying. The beans are spread out in thin layers and raked regularly to ensure even drying. This slow process, which can take a week or more, helps to mellow out some of the remaining acidity, further developing the flavor.
Now, let's talk about roasting. We know, we know—we just said raw cacao is unroasted. And that's mostly true. However, a very light, low-temperature roast is often performed. We’re talking temperatures around 115-120°F (46-49°C), which is just enough to kill any surface pathogens, loosen the shell for easier removal, and bring out a little more of that nutty, chocolatey aroma without destroying the precious enzymes and nutrients. This is a far cry from the 250-350°F temperatures used for making commercial cocoa.
For a home process, you can achieve this by spreading the dried beans on a baking sheet and placing them in an oven set to its lowest temperature for about 15-20 minutes. You should start to smell a gentle chocolate aroma. That's your cue. Any more than that and you're moving into cocoa territory.
Once the beans are dried and lightly toasted, it's time to remove their thin, papery outer shells. This process is called winnowing. The goal is to be left with pure cacao nibs.
First, you need to crack the beans. You can do this by placing them in a bag and gently rolling over them with a rolling pin or by pulsing them very briefly in a food processor. You don't want to pulverize them, just break them into smaller pieces and separate the husk from the nib.
Next comes the separation. The traditional method is to toss the cracked beans in the air, allowing a breeze to carry away the lighter husks while the heavier nibs fall back into the bowl. You can replicate this at home using a bowl and a hairdryer set to cool. It’s messy, but it’s surprisingly effective. Work in small batches and do it outside if you can! The husks, by the way, aren't trash. They can be steeped to make a delicious, light chocolate-flavored tea.
What you're left with are cacao nibs—the pure, broken-up heart of the bean. You could stop here and enjoy them as-is, but we're on a mission to make powder.
This is the stage where solid nibs transform into a liquid paste. Cacao nibs are roughly 50% fat (cacao butter). When you grind them, the friction generates heat, which melts the fat and turns the whole mass into a thick, flowing liquid known as cacao liquor or cacao mass. It's 100% pure chocolate, with nothing added and nothing removed (yet).
Achieving this requires a powerful machine. A standard blender or food processor will struggle and likely burn out. You need something that can handle continuous grinding. A high-powered blender like a Vitamix or Blendtec can work, but you'll need to work in small batches and use the tamper to keep the mixture moving. A more specialized piece of equipment is a stone grinder, also called a melanger, which is designed for this exact purpose.
| Grinding Method | Pros | Cons | Our Team's Recommendation |
|---|---|---|---|
| High-Powered Blender | Fast, accessible for many households. | Can easily overheat the motor and the cacao. Requires careful monitoring. | A good starting point, but watch the temperature closely. Stop and let it cool if needed. |
| Stone Grinder/Melanger | Creates an incredibly smooth, fine paste. Low-temperature grinding. | Expensive, specialized equipment. A slow process (can take hours). | The gold standard for artisan quality. An investment for the serious cacao enthusiast. |
| Champion Juicer | Surprisingly effective at creating a coarse paste quickly. | Does not produce a truly fine liquid liquor. Better as a pre-grinder. | A viable option if you have one, but you'll likely need to refine the paste in a blender. |
Regardless of the method, the goal is to grind until the paste is completely smooth and liquid when warm. This can take anywhere from 20 minutes to several hours, depending on your equipment.
Here it is. The defining moment in making cacao powder. To get a dry powder, you have to remove most of the fat. This is the single most challenging step to replicate in a home kitchen because it requires immense pressure.
Industrially, the cacao liquor is put into a powerful hydraulic press that exerts thousands of pounds of force, squeezing out the beautiful, pale-yellow cacao butter. What remains in the press is a solid, compressed disc of cacao solids called a "press cake."
So, how can you do this at home? A hydraulic shop press is the most direct way, but it's not exactly standard kitchen equipment. A more accessible (though less efficient) method is to use a high-quality tincture press or a very sturdy cheese press. You'll pour the warm cacao liquor into a fine-mesh press bag, place it in the press, and slowly apply pressure. You'll see the golden cacao butter begin to drip out. Collect this liquid gold in a jar—it's an amazing ingredient for skincare or for making your own white chocolate.
You won't be able to remove as much fat as a commercial press, so your homemade powder will likely have a higher fat content (around 20-25% instead of 10-12%). This isn't a bad thing! It just means it will be richer and a bit more caloric. It’s a more whole-food version.
You've done it. You've pressed the liquor and now you have your cacao press cake. It will be hard and solid. The final step is to turn this into a fine powder.
Break the cake into smaller, manageable chunks. You can then grind these pieces into powder using a clean coffee grinder, a spice grinder, or a high-powered blender. Work in small batches to avoid overheating the motor and to ensure you get a very fine, consistent powder. Sift the resulting powder through a fine-mesh sieve to remove any larger clumps, and then re-grind the clumps. Repeat until all of it is a beautiful, fluffy, and incredibly aromatic powder.
Congratulations. You have just learned how to make cacao powder the authentic way. Store it in an airtight container in a cool, dark place. It will be more potent and flavorful than anything you've ever bought.
Now that you have this incredible, homemade ingredient, you can elevate your wellness rituals. This pure cacao is the perfect carrier for other potent botanicals. It’s where our world of functional mushrooms truly shines. Imagine starting your day not just with the energizing theobromine of cacao, but with an added scoop of our Lift Mushrooms FOR Energy blend, featuring Cordyceps and Lion's Mane. It’s a combination designed to Boost Energy, Focus & Recovery Naturally.
For a cognitive edge during a demanding workday, try adding a serving of our Mind Lions Mane Mushroom Supplement to your cacao drink. The synergy is fantastic. The cacao provides gentle stimulation while the Lion's Mane supports mental clarity and focus. It's a simple, powerful way to Unlock Your Daily Wellness Boost. This is what we mean by functional nutrition—using pure ingredients in intelligent combinations to support your body's optimal state.
After reading through this sprawling process, you might be wondering if it's all worth the effort. Our answer is an unequivocal yes.
When you make your own cacao powder, you control every single step. You ensure its purity. You preserve its incredible nutritional integrity. We're talking about one of the highest sources of antioxidants on the planet, packed with magnesium for muscle and nerve function, iron for energy, and mood-elevating compounds like anandamide and phenylethylamine (PEA). Theobromine, its primary stimulant, provides a longer, more sustained energy lift than caffeine, without the jittery side effects.
This isn't just about making a food product. It's about reclaiming a connection to your food, understanding its journey from a humble bean to a wellness-boosting powder. It’s a process that mirrors our own philosophy at Non Fungible Mushrooms: that the best things come from nature, treated with respect, and understood with scientific rigor. It's a challenging, rewarding, and ultimately delicious endeavor that will change the way you think about chocolate forever.
We strongly advise against it. Fermentation is a critical, non-negotiable step that develops the classic chocolate flavor profile and reduces bitterness. Without it, your final powder will taste astringent and flat, lacking all complexity.
In the initial stages, the white substance is the natural fruit pulp of the cacao pod, which is being consumed by yeasts. Later, you might see some white, yeast-based mold, which is a normal part of the process. However, black, green, or fuzzy mold indicates a problem with airflow or temperature.
Grinding nibs creates cacao paste, or liquor, which is about 50% fat (cacao butter). To make powder, you must physically press out a significant portion of that fat. Cacao powder is what's left over *after* the butter has been extracted.
Store it in a completely airtight container, like a glass jar with a good seal. Keep it in a cool, dark, and dry place, such as a pantry or cupboard. Proper storage will protect its flavor and potency for many months.
It's a multi-day process. Fermentation typically takes 5-7 days, followed by another 5-7 days of sun-drying. The active work of roasting, winnowing, grinding, and pressing can take several hours, depending on your equipment.
Absolutely. By controlling the process and using low temperatures, you preserve a much higher concentration of antioxidants, enzymes, and minerals compared to commercially produced, high-heat roasted cocoa powder. It's a significantly more potent superfood.
No, a coffee grinder is only suitable for the final step of grinding the pressed cacao cake into powder. It is not powerful enough to turn the nibs into liquid cacao liquor and the motor would likely burn out.
Cacao butter is a prized ingredient! It's a healthy, stable fat perfect for making your own chocolate, adding to smoothies for richness, or using in natural skincare products like lotions and lip balms. Don't throw it away.
This is usually due to a higher fat content than commercial powders, as home presses are less efficient. Sifting the powder through a fine-mesh sieve after grinding will break up the clumps and give you a finer texture.
Cacao contains a very small amount of caffeine, but its primary stimulant is theobromine. Theobromine provides a more gentle, sustained energy boost without the sharp spike and crash often associated with caffeine.
The difference is dramatic. Homemade cacao has a much more complex, intense, and often fruity flavor profile that reflects the specific bean varietal. It's less one-dimensionally 'chocolatey' and far more interesting than standard cocoa powder.
Initially, there is an investment in quality beans and potentially some equipment. However, on a per-ounce basis for true, high-quality raw cacao powder, it can be quite cost-effective in the long run, especially if you make it in larger batches.
Yes, absolutely. The winnowed husks make a wonderful, light-bodied tea. Simply steep them in hot water for 5-10 minutes for a beverage with a delicate chocolate aroma and flavor, but with virtually no calories or fat.
Previous Post